Letting the customer set the price sounds like a way to lose money, and in most catalogues it is. In four specific situations, however, it can earn more than a fixed price, and whether it does depends mostly on how the price field is set up.
Contents
When letting the customer set the price works
Letting the customer set the price works in four cases, and they have one thing in common: the product has no obvious market price, so any fixed price is only the seller's guess about what the customer is willing to pay.
Donations and tips are the clearest case. There is no correct amount, the customer knows what the cause is worth to them, and a fixed amount limits those who would give more while putting off those who would give less.
Pay-what-you-want digital products are the second. Selling one more copy costs almost nothing, so nearly every sale at any price adds to the margin, and customers who pay more help the product reach people who would not buy it at a fixed price.
Gift cards are the third and the most ordinary commercial case. A customer buying a present has a budget no store can guess, and a fixed set of values loses the sales that fall between them.
The fourth is a deposit or part payment, where the customer pays part of the amount now and the rest later. In a B2B store, a customer price field can handle this without any extra tools.
How to set the field up so it does not lose money
Set a minimum price. This setting matters most, and for products that cost you something it should be at or above that cost, not at zero.
Set a suggested amount, higher than you expect customers to pay. The suggested price works as a reference point, many customers pay close to it, and stores that set it too low get exactly what they suggested.
Consider a maximum price for anything that affects shipping or accounting, because a field without a limit invites test orders with absurd amounts, and sooner or later somebody will place one.
Keep the field on the product page, not in the cart. A price set at checkout feels like a negotiation, while a price set on the product page feels like a choice.
What it does to the rest of the store
It changes what your reports mean. When customers set prices, average order value depends more on them than on your price list, so a catalogue that mixes fixed and customer-set prices needs the two kinds of orders analysed separately before any average makes sense. We write more about such questions in our article on the five questions about your sales you should be able to answer.
It also affects discounts, which is worth deciding in advance. A percentage discount on a price the customer chose is correct mathematically but makes little sense, which is why many stores exclude products with customer-set prices from catalogue promotions.
The lowest-price obligation usually does not apply here, because a price set by the customer is not a reduction announced by the store. This holds as long as you do not advertise the lower amounts as a discount from the suggested price.
The minimum and the suggested amount are the two settings that decide whether this earns or costs. Custom Price for WooCommerce PRO puts both on the product page, with an optional maximum, so the field is a bounded choice rather than an open box.
Summary
Letting the customer set the price works when the product has no obvious market price. There are four such cases: donations and tips, where no amount is correct; pay-what-you-want digital products, where an extra copy costs almost nothing; gift cards, where the buyer has a budget no store can guess; and deposits or part payments in B2B stores. Four settings decide whether the price field earns or loses money: a minimum price at or above cost, a suggested amount set higher than feels comfortable, because many customers pay close to it, a maximum price for anything that affects shipping or accounting, and the field placed on the product page rather than in the cart. Customer-set prices also change the meaning of average order value, so such orders should be analysed separately, and many stores exclude them from catalogue promotions. The lowest-price obligation usually does not apply, as long as the store does not advertise lower amounts as a discount.
Frequently asked questions
Will customers pay the minimum?
Some will, and the suggested amount decides how many. With a well-chosen suggestion, the average payment is often close to it.
Can a name-your-price product also have a regular price?
Usually it has a suggested price that works as the default. This is not the same as a regular price, and a customer paying less is not getting a reduction.
Does this work for physical products?
Rarely, because shipping and production costs set a lower limit that customers cannot see. If you use it for physical products, the minimum price has to cover those costs.


